Which do you choose?

Here's a question for all you bloggers out there. Tell me which one you find more romantic and meaningful.

1. When a man asks you to marry him and spend the rest of your lives together. He has chosen you to walk hand in hand into forever. You're young, optimistic, and in love.

OR

2. When you have been married for quite some time, you have struggled, fought, loved, laughed, and cried through good times and bad. Then he looks at you, both of you a bit older and wiser, and says that he would gladly do it all over again.